EDR vs XDR: Which is the better cybersecurity solution?

With every technological advance, new malware variants emerge, as well as more sophisticated attack techniques and more complex environments to protect. In this context, tools such as EDR (Endpoint Detection and Response) and XDR (Extended Detection and Response) have become key pieces in the cybersecurity strategy of many organizations.

While both solutions play a crucial role, understanding their differences may not be as straightforward as it seems. EDR, more established and focused exclusively on endpoints, collects activity data from laptops, desktops and mobile devices. It was a significant leap forward from traditional antivirus, thanks to capabilities such as user behavioral analysis (UEBA), which enables the detection of anomalous patterns and potential threats.

XDR, on the other hand, represents a natural evolution of EDR. This newer technology expands the scope by integrating multiple data sources (such as email, network, cloud and endpoints) to provide a unified view of the entire IT infrastructure. In addition, thanks to its single-pane-of-glass approach, it allows you to coordinate more effective responses to incidents that might go unnoticed if dealt with in isolation.

So is it worth making the leap to XDR, or is EDR still sufficient for many organizations? In this article we will explore the key differences between the two solutions, their advantages, limitations and which may be best suited to your organization's real needs.

What is an EDR?

If you haven't read our article on what an EDR is, here is a brief summary to get you up to speed. In a nutshell, EDR (Endpoint Detection and Response) is a technology designed to protect the devices we use every day at work: laptops, desktops, mobiles, tablets... anything that connects to your network. These devices (also known as endpoints) are one of the favorite targets of cyber-attacks, and it's no coincidence.

EDR works as a kind of digital watchdog. An agent is installed on each device that monitors in real time everything that happens: changes in files, suspicious network connections, strange user or application behavior... basically, any signal that could indicate a threat.

All this information is sent to a central platform where it is constantly analyzed. If something looks dangerous - for example, a file performing unusual actions - the system automatically alerts the security team.

And the best part: modern EDRs not only detect, they also respond. If configured correctly, the system can take immediate action, such as isolating a compromised computer to prevent potential malware from spreading across the network.

What is XDR?

If you already know what EDR is, then understanding XDR is the next logical step. In fact, we could say that XDR is an evolution of EDR. While EDR focuses on protecting devices (such as laptops, PCs, mobiles), XDR extends that focus to cover an enterprise's entire infrastructure: network, cloud, email, servers and more.

Now, while EDR is useful, it's not perfect. It can be costly to implement and requires considerable time, technical resources and trained personnel to get the most out of it. In addition, with work teams becoming more and more distributed and using different devices from different locations, blind spots start to appear that complicate the detection of complex threats. That's where XDR really shines.

Why all the fuss about XDR?

Because XDR breaks with the traditional fragmented security model. It brings together all the information that was previously scattered (across tools like EDR, firewalls, mail systems, cloud platforms, etc.) and centralizes it in one place. That gives the security team a much clearer and more complete view of what's going on.

The benefit? Less time reviewing single alerts and more context to understand what kind of threat you're facing. XDR automatically correlates alerts and detects patterns that might go unnoticed if analyzed separately.

One of the great benefits of XDR is that it turns analysts into true threat hunters, not just alert snuffers. By analyzing data from different layers of the IT environment, XDR helps to understand the “how” and “why” behind an attack: what techniques attackers are using, how they are moving within the network, and where they might strike next.

This view with more context not only improves response, but reduces manual investigation time and allows you to act before the damage is done.

Less noise, more efficiency

Another plus point of XDR is that it drastically reduces noise in analysts' inboxes. Instead of hundreds of disconnected alerts, XDR groups them together, filters them and displays only what really matters. Thus, the security team can focus on the urgent and not waste time on false positives or minor incidents. In addition, by integrating with the security framework you already have in place, XDR becomes a powerful booster that improves your overall security posture without the need to reinvent your entire architecture.

Read more:  What Is XDR? The Future of Cyber Threat Detection & Response

XDR vs. EDR: how do they differ and which one is right for you?

EDR and XDR are two different ways of tackling the same problem: cybersecurity threats. But while they have similar goals, they do so in quite different ways.

EDR was, for a long time, the flagship tool for monitoring and responding to threats on devices such as laptops, desktops and mobiles. It focuses exclusively on endpoints and does an excellent job of detecting suspicious behavior within those devices. If you are concerned about protecting your computers directly, EDR does the job very well.

XDR, on the other hand, takes it a step further. Instead of focusing just on devices, it collects information from all fronts: network, cloud, email, endpoints... everything. And by bringing all that data together on the same platform, it can see the big picture and detect more sophisticated attacks that might go unnoticed if you only looked at one area.

Less effort, more context

One of the great advantages of XDR is that it relieves some of the operational burden on security teams. Instead of reviewing a thousand separate alerts, everything arrives more orderly, correlated and with context. This makes incident response much easier and allows complex patterns to be detected more accurately.

While EDR requires the team to be more on top of things, XDR automates much of the analysis and reduces the time analysts spend doing manual investigations.

It depends on your situation. If your priority is to protect specific devices and you don't need to monitor other channels such as network or mail, EDR may be sufficient and easier to manage.

But if you are looking for a more comprehensive and connected security strategy, capable of detecting threats that move through different vectors (such as phishing, malware in the cloud or lateral movements within the network), then XDR has much more to offer.

Comparison: XDR vs EDR

Conclusión

If you're just starting out or your security approach is ad hoc, EDR can be a good start. But if you're already dealing with more advanced threats or want to stay ahead of more sophisticated attacks, XDR can give you a huge advantage, especially because of its ability to view the entire IT ecosystem as a whole.

At TecnetOne, we offer advanced cybersecurity solutions like EDR and XDR, designed to protect, monitor and respond to threats in real time. Whether you need a defense focused on your devices or comprehensive protection for your entire infrastructure, we help you choose, implement and manage the solution that best fits your business. Not sure where to start? Contact us. Our team of specialists can help you build a solid cybersecurity strategy.